A Heavy Metal Fairy Tale

This week in class, we watched an interesting music video by the German heavy metal band Rammstein. The video's story line heavily referenced the story of Snow White and the Seven Dwarves, but with several...unique...changes. For one thing, the video focuses only on Snow White and the Dwarves and does not show the evil queen at all. Instead, the "villain" of the story appears to be Snow White herself, who seems to be oppressing and abusing the Dwarves, forcing them to mine gold and serve her. The Dwarves eventually rebel and (seemingly reluctantly) kill her. They place her at the top of a mountain in a glass coffin, but an apple falls through the top of the coffin, shattering it, and releasing an apparently (and perhaps understandably) angry Snow White. 

Image result for snow white rammstein halloI have now watched this video a couple of times and, to tell the truth, am still not completely confident I know what it is supposed to mean. The best theory that I've been able to come up with has to do with a detail that I noticed at around the two minute thirty second mark. In this scene, the Dwarves are crowded around Snow White, embracing and bowing down to her. If you look carefully, you will notice that the position in which Snow White is standing places her head right in the center of a circular window behind her, giving her what appears to be a halo (see picture above). This detail seems to imply some kind of connection between Snow White and the divine, so I watched the video again, looking for any more imagery that could be interpreted as religious.

Image result for nietzscheAs I was watching the video through this new lens, I was suddenly reminded of a particular feature of Fredrick Nietzsche's critique of religion. In the Third Essay of On the Genealogy of Morals, Nietzsche characterizes belief in God (and, before that, belief in an obligation to the ancestor) as a kind of abusive relationship, in which we try to do things to please a deity, but are never able to pay back the deity for what he/she has supposedly done for us, resulting in ever growing feelings of guilt and bad conscious. In the Rammstein video, a similar dynamic seems to be at play between the Dwarves and Snow White, with the latter taking offerings of gold from the former and yet still continuing to abuse them. The Dwarves in turn, seem to treat Snow White with a combination of fear, reverence, and desire, almost as if she is a god to them,


The ending of the video, then, can perhaps be seen as the Dwarves finally "killing God" in the form of Snow White, an act which seems to free them in some sense, but also makes them feel sad and guilty. When Snow White is freed by the falling apple (that's more possibly religious symbolism, though I'm not quite sure what it means yet), the Dwarves, unable to escape from their guilt, return to her. 

Now, to be sure, I do not know if the members of Rammstein are fans of Nietzsche (I do believe he was, at one time at least, pretty popular in some punk/metal circles), but this may not matter, since the critique of religion as a producer of guilt is not necessarily singular to him. Personally, I am neither an atheist, nor a fan of heavy metal, but I do find Nietzsche interesting, so I suppose I did enjoyed the video at least as a possible representation of these ideas, if not for its portrayal of Snow White spanking the Dwarves. šŸ˜¬

Anyways, I will certainly be interested to see how everybody else interpreted this and hope that we discuss it a little more in class on Tuesday.


Picture Credits:
https://www.pinterest.com.au/pin/496381190152953222/
https://www.biography.com/people/friedrich-nietzsche-9423452

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What are Fairy and Folk Tales?

Image
If we are going to be spending the next several weeks discussing folk and fairy tales, I think that it will be useful to try and first define what exactly we mean by these two terms. Based on what we've read so far and the discussions we've had in class, it seems that there are at least two main features of folk and fairy tales which we might examine in order to help us to get at what they are and how they relate to each other and to other pieces of literature.  The most important feature of both a folk tale and a fairy tale is the presence of magic or other fantastical elements in the story. A folk or fairy tale might, for example, involve characters such as witches or fairy godmothers who can perform magic and make impossible things happen, or it might include strange creatures such as ogres or talking animals. Typically, the story will also involve a regular person (often a young person) interacting with the magical elements of the world. Bettelheim argues that these ma...
Read more

The Poetry of Arabic Folktales

Image
This week, McDaniel Arabic Professor Carol Zaru came in to tale to our class about Arabic folktales. Much like in the other cultures that we have looked so far, the Arabic tales were told both for entertainment and to pass on certain moral lessons. Arabic tales for entertainment include the stories of the Thousand and One Nights and the stories of Joha, a simpleton or trickster character who has spread and been adapted by cultures throughout the Middle East, North Africa, and the Mediterranean. Stories about him are often short and humorous, reminding me a little of some of the Jewish stories we have read, such as "A Dispute in Sign Language" or "Chelm Justice." Another kind of Arabic story features two jackals named Kalila and Dimna. These tales originated in the court of an Indian king, but spread across the Middle East as tales which provide the hearer with wisdom and moral knowledge. One feature of Arabic tales I found to be particularly interesting is the rol...
Read more

Conclusion

Image
Well, this is it. My final blog post. Over the past several weeks, I have learned a lot of interesting things about fairy tales and was exposed to a variety that I had no idea existed. At the beginning of the semester, I mentioned that I was excited to read tales from other cultures and was very happy that this is exactly what we ended up doing. Of the atlas of tales that we read, I think that my favorite were probably the Native American and Arabic ones for their beauty and humor.  I also really enjoyed the modern short stories, films, and cartoons that we analyzed for their relationships to the classic fairy tales. It was fascinating to see how these tales continue to permeate our culture and I even found my favorite tale of the ones we have read this semester in Oscar Wildeā€™s ā€œThe Nightingale and the Rose.ā€ The critical theories articulated by von Franz and Bettelheim were very interesting too. I especially liked Bettelheimā€™s notion of fairy tales as something that children ca...
Read more