The Nightingale and the Rose

Recently, philosopher and activist Dr. Cornel West came to McDaniel and delivered an amazing talk which covered a variety of topics. One part of his talk that particularly touched me and, I think, a lot of other students here at McDaniel who participate in the music program, was a comparison that he made between music and acts of giving. In a good musical performance, he said, a person pours their entire self into their performance so that those listening can be filled with whatever emotion they hear in the music. Likewise, the greatest acts of charity are those that involve giving our whole selves to help others or further a cause.

Oscar Wilde, I think, understood this idea quite well, as he expresses it beautifully in his story "The Nightingale and the Rose." In an especially powerful scene, the Nightingale pierces her heart on a thorn, singing all the while the most beautiful song that has ever been heard, so that a young student can have a red rose to give to the woman he loves. In the end, the woman rejects the student and he renounces love in favor of cold logic, but the Nightingale's whole-bodied sacrifice for another stands as an inherently good and beautiful thing. 

Related imageThe message conveyed by West and Wilde is, I think, one which has not and never will decay in its importance. Especially here in the United States, we seem to give plenty of lip service to kind of outwardly quiet, yet inwardly powerful self-sacrifice of the Nightingale, but this is also displaced to an extent by an additional, materialistic definition of success. In our elections, we often see business men running for office, claiming that they are perfect candidates because of the managerial skills which allowed them to make so much money. These skills may well be practically useful, but can it really be said that they should be sought over (or even generally coincide with) the kind of willingness for self sacrifice that has traditionally been associated with the Christian definition of "service?" Certainly it is no crime to make money, but should we really be using it as a factor when judging somebody's character or fitness for public office? Our children's books seem to say "no," but our actions (we are, after all, only human) too often say otherwise. 

In the fairy tales of Oscar Wilde, the world is a dark and cruel place in which the rich get richer, the poor poorer, and the good die underappreciated. The beauty of their acts, however, viewable only by us readers, still gives us hope that the importance of self-sacrifice will one day be fully recognized and that we will ourselves might be able to find projects into which we are able to pour our whole selves. 


Picture Credits:
https://sites.google.com/site/ssuirp4b1/the-nightingale-and-the-rose

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What are Fairy and Folk Tales?

Image
If we are going to be spending the next several weeks discussing folk and fairy tales, I think that it will be useful to try and first define what exactly we mean by these two terms. Based on what we've read so far and the discussions we've had in class, it seems that there are at least two main features of folk and fairy tales which we might examine in order to help us to get at what they are and how they relate to each other and to other pieces of literature.  The most important feature of both a folk tale and a fairy tale is the presence of magic or other fantastical elements in the story. A folk or fairy tale might, for example, involve characters such as witches or fairy godmothers who can perform magic and make impossible things happen, or it might include strange creatures such as ogres or talking animals. Typically, the story will also involve a regular person (often a young person) interacting with the magical elements of the world. Bettelheim argues that these ma...
Read more

The Poetry of Arabic Folktales

Image
This week, McDaniel Arabic Professor Carol Zaru came in to tale to our class about Arabic folktales. Much like in the other cultures that we have looked so far, the Arabic tales were told both for entertainment and to pass on certain moral lessons. Arabic tales for entertainment include the stories of the Thousand and One Nights and the stories of Joha, a simpleton or trickster character who has spread and been adapted by cultures throughout the Middle East, North Africa, and the Mediterranean. Stories about him are often short and humorous, reminding me a little of some of the Jewish stories we have read, such as "A Dispute in Sign Language" or "Chelm Justice." Another kind of Arabic story features two jackals named Kalila and Dimna. These tales originated in the court of an Indian king, but spread across the Middle East as tales which provide the hearer with wisdom and moral knowledge. One feature of Arabic tales I found to be particularly interesting is the rol...
Read more

Conclusion

Image
Well, this is it. My final blog post. Over the past several weeks, I have learned a lot of interesting things about fairy tales and was exposed to a variety that I had no idea existed. At the beginning of the semester, I mentioned that I was excited to read tales from other cultures and was very happy that this is exactly what we ended up doing. Of the atlas of tales that we read, I think that my favorite were probably the Native American and Arabic ones for their beauty and humor.  I also really enjoyed the modern short stories, films, and cartoons that we analyzed for their relationships to the classic fairy tales. It was fascinating to see how these tales continue to permeate our culture and I even found my favorite tale of the ones we have read this semester in Oscar Wilde’s “The Nightingale and the Rose.” The critical theories articulated by von Franz and Bettelheim were very interesting too. I especially liked Bettelheim’s notion of fairy tales as something that children ca...
Read more